GO
Blog updated
6/11/2008
Back
Blood Diamond
Warner Bros
Certificate: 15
Starring: Leonardo DiCaprio, Jennifer Connelly, Djimon Hounsou
Director: Edward Zwick
Aspect ratio: 2.4:1
Running time: 143 mins
Audio options: English Dolby Digital 5.1, English PCM 5.1, Spanish 5.1, French 5.1.

Film synopsis: This tale of a smuggler and a fishermen taking on a sinister syndicate of businessmen and the carnage of war-torn Sierra Leone in a bid to secure themselves a priceless diamond is supposed to be politically charged. But although the missus found it suitably powerful, I have to admit I found the whole thing a bit too 'Hollywoodised' for comfort.

Picture quality
I’m beginning to note a bit of a depressing trend in Blu-rays from Warners: excessive amounts of video noise during dark scenes. This is immediately apparent with Blood Diamond, as the very first shots, inside Solomon Vandy’s room as he gets his son up, suffer with some really pretty ugly fizzing and grain. Black levels don’t seem quite as deep as I’d have expected, either – it’s almost as if they’ve been artificially lightened or something.

The difference between dark and bright scenes with the Blood Diamond Blu-ray is like someone pressing the ‘HD’ button. For instance, soon after the noisy grimness of the opening scene I mentioned we get a shot of nasty thugs driving towards Vandy’s village that looks really quite superb. There's sensational detailing and sumptuously rich colouring in the green foliage around the jeep, not to mention stunning subtlety in the portrayal of the skin tones of the jeep's occupants and the dust cloud behind it. Plus there’s little if any grain and dot crawl. And remember, this is all happening on an image packed with motion. Superb stuff.

But of course, Blood Diamond is not a film comprising exclusively bright scenes. And every time a dark one arrives, the accompanying noise can be bad enough to actually disengage you from the film.

Plus there are a couple of other negatives. First, I felt like the colours sometimes bleached out a little during extremely bright scenes. Second, rather freakily the picture seems out of focus at the top and especially bottom during certain shots. It’s possible this is some curious filter or anamorphic effect created during filming, as the subtitles seem perfectly in focus even when the picture behind them is not. Then again, the subtitles may be superimposed after the film’s been copied from the master… Oh, alright. Basically, I haven’t got a clue what’s going on. But I certainly do know that it's bloody annoying. Overall, I don’t think there’s any other HD title I’ve seen that’s given me so many picture highs and lows. Which is nice-reviewer speak for 'it’s a royal mess'.

I should add before concluding here, by the way, that the transfer is a 2.4:1 aspect ratio, encoded in 1080p/24.

Sound quality
The English Dolby Digital 5.1 mix the film defaults to (French and Spanish 5.1 versions are available too) is rather unusual in that it has to be played way louder than you’d normally expect in order to get much from it. Seriously, initially I thought I’d got the wrong input selected as there didn’t seem to be any sound at all coming out.

Once you’ve got your home cinema system set suitably loud, however, the soundstage turns out to be surprisingly good. Not because it does anything particularly clever in terms of subtle effects, but because it knows how to burst into life when required. As the government troops raid the R.U.F. diamond mine, for instance, the explosions of the grenades shake the room, with prodigious amounts of bass erupting from your subwoofer while your main speakers suddenly seem to have been turned to ‘11’. (Sorry about the This Is Spinal Tap reference there, but sometimes it just has to be done.) Yet as a sign of how carefully the whole thing has been mixed, you can still clearly make out every individual bullet and every word that’s said even when a grenade feels like it’s just gone off right under your feet. Mind you, the dialogue clarity has the unfortunate side effect of revealing what we’ll charitably call one or two interesting ‘dialects’ to Leonardo DiCaprio’s African accent.

Having praised the Dolby Digital mix so highly, I can now reveal that this mix isn’t even the star of the audio show. That’s actually the PCM 5.1 mix, with its uncompressed HD audio. This delivers even greater bass extension, if it’s possible, than the Dolby Digital one, and generally just sounds that bit richer.

Actually, although this might sound a bit daft, for me the Blood Diamond soundtrack is almost too well engineered. For it fits into that sense I mentioned earlier of this being too much of a Hollywood production, with all the high production values detracting from the ‘grit’ of the subject matter. But hey, that’s just a personal view related to my response to the film. As a serious tester of your sound system, Blood Diamond is, surprisingly, mustard.

Extra features
The Blood Diamond Blu-ray's extra features aren't quite as comprehensive as those of the same film on HD DVD. But as you can see from the list below, they still add up to a mighty satisfying package.
1. Audio-only commentary with director Edward Zwick.
2. 'Blood on the Stone' documentary, showing how 'conflict diamonds' can still get to the west in contravention of the Kimberley Process.
3. Becoming Archer featurette, focussing on DiCaprio's role in the film.
4. Journalists on the Front Line featurette, talking about how real female warzone journalists inspired Jennifer Connelly's role and performance.
5. Inside the Siege of Freetown featurette, looking at how they did the major battle scene in Freetown.
6. Series of 23 individually accessible production featurettes - the same ones found in the In Movie Experience on the HD DVD.
7. 'Shine on em' music video by Naz.
8. Theatrical trailer.

For a review of every feature on the disc, click here.
Presentation
Boring with a capital B. Pressing the Menu button while watching the film just brings up a little strip of options along the bottom of the screen, while the ‘deeper’ menus are just static, graphics-free affairs (except for the scene selection option which does at least muster a still from each chapter it lists).

The Extra Features menu is particularly nightmarish, presenting you as it does with a truly terrifying face full of nothing but text...


The Last Word
Warners should be heartily congratulated on the extra features it’s managed to get together for this disc – especially the In-Movie Experience, which combines true next-gen presentation techniques with plenty of genuinely informative supplemental material.

Occasionally the Blu-ray's pictures sparkle technically, too.

It’s just a pity that these periods of sparkle are joined by just as many moments of messiness.


12/20
18/20
16/20
4/10
72%

When Archer is summoned to Colonel Coetzee’s vineyard, the level of detail in the facial close-ups and the vegetation and landscape around them is a sight for HD-hungry eyes. Chapter 8, 31mins 23secs.

Or if you want an HD audio highlight, try out the main attack by General Coetzee’s attack chopper on the mines. Chapter 26, 1hr 47mins 49secs.

Jennifer Connelly hurt her neck quite badly while filming Blood Diamond’s main car chase scene. As a result she had to take some pretty serious pain medication for a while, which led to an unfortunate evening where she decided to combine the meds with a drink or three, and ended up telling someone at the dinner table that she thought she ought to edit the film herself, despite having no editing training. That ‘someone at the table’ was, of course, the film’s editor, Steven Rosenblum...

Later that same night she also tried to take over from the DJ at a local club, and had to be rescued before things got ugly by her (lucky, lucky, lucky sod of a) husband, British actor Paul Bettany.

Bless her. And there was me thinking actors were all shy and retiring.

To send an email to HD WARS to enquire about advertising or licensing content, click here.
Copyright © 2008 John Archer Ltd.